Home
Spaceman

Klaatu and Gort's Excellent Adventure.

Variety is reporting that Keanu Reeves will play Klaatu in a remake of The Day the Earth Stood Still.

Set aside for a moment the fact that this is one of my all-time favorite movies, and in my opinion doesn't need to be remade, and the very notion of doing so borders on heresy.

Set aside for a moment the certainty that Hollywood will find a way to strip from this film the message (overt as it was) it conveyed so well more than 50 years ago and turn it into a 90-minute commercial for crappy action figures and video games -- to say nothing of the fact that, sadly, it's a message that still needs conveying -- and instead give us a "visual feast" of new special effects that were all but unnecessary in the original version. I'll bet some jackass in a production office is trying to find a way to turn this into a comedy, with Gort playing the part of the smart-assed sidekick who also has the ability to turn the entire planet into a flaming turd on the galactic porch with a flip of his visor.

Set all of that aside.

Instead, let the jokes begin. I'm already twitching as classic dialogue is "re-imagined" for modern audiences:

Rather than:

"I came here to give you these facts. It is no concern of ours how you run your own planet. But if you threaten to extend your violence, this Earth of yours will be reduced to a burned-out cinder."

We'll get:

"Listen up. We don't care about your planet, dudes, but if you roll up on us the wrong way, we'll smoke your asses."

Or, instead of:

"There must be security for all, or no one is secure. This does not mean giving up any freedom, except the freedom to act irresponsibly."

We'll have:

"Be excellent to each other."

And naturally, they'll want to replace:

"We have come to visit you in peace and with goodwill."

With:

"Whoa."

Crap.
Tags: ,

Comments

This is the most depressing thing I've read in a long time...
Heh

Actually, if they *have* to remake it (and it's a bad idea, right down there with remaking Enter The Dragon) - he's not that bad a choice- being half-Hawaiian, he's got a sort of exotic look that could work well, as Michael Rennie did.
Apparently the shit-tastic remake of War of the Worlds didn't teach Hollywood that you don't fuck with the classics.
You know they want to do this with "Forbidden Planet" too?

I know it's been talked about for about a decade. I'll believe it when I start seeing casting notes.

To paraphrase Harlan Ellison, you don't remake a movie that was done right the first time.
I *LOVE* "Forbidden Planet."

They could NEVER do justice to the original.

They'd try to "fix" everything.

Yuck!!!

I'm sure we'll be told that it's not really a remake, but instead a new take on the original short story "Farewell to the Master."

Or, they might have the gall to do what was done with The Invasion, and try to pass it off as a "whole new idea," rather than just another Body Snatchers remake.
Or Planet of the Apes. Or The Time Machine. Or.... etc.

I'm not opposed to remakes in general, as there have been several that have done quite well (SF examples include The Fly, The Thing, Invasion of the Body Snatchers). I'm looking forward to (and crossing my fingers for) I Am Legend, too. I just hope they don't screw the pooch on that one, as it's one of my favorite SF novels.

I'm more opposed to an updating of stuff like TDTESS because of Hollywood's recent track record for remaking and updating, which has left me cynical.

I know that shocks you. :)

About all I can say so far on I Am Legend is that they really did their best to make New York look deserted. I still remember walking past St. Patrick's the day they were filming and seeing how the set decorators had really done a fine job of aging the location.
I'm nervous about I Am Legend only because I really enjoyed watching "The Omega Man" when I was a kid.

Sure, there's always another take you can do on a story, but for every "The Thing" they do, there's also "War of the Worlds", "Solaris" and "Lost in Space".

(And I'll let "Dune" rest in pieces
I'm still waiting for the threatened remake of Casablanca.

You know, any movie that's in black and white CAN'T possibly be any good.
I actually know people who say and believe this.
I'm still waiting for the threatened remake of Casablanca.

It was called Barb Wire.

Not forgetting two TV series versions, in 1955 and 1983 (with David Soul as Rick, yet!)
"Dude, my robot is going to, like, totally kick your ass."
Well at least it isn't as bad as when they cast Mr. 'Whoa' as Siddhartha in the movie "Little Buddha".
AAAHHHHHHH!!!!

July 2009

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Advertisement

Powered by LiveJournal.com